Rollback: PRD Quality Restored (98/100)
Rolled back v7.8.13 optimizations - aggressive conciseness reduced PRD quality from 98/100 to 82/100.
Why Rollback
| Version | Score | Lines | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| v7.8.12 | 98/100 | 761 | AI-first design, comprehensive |
| v7.8.13 | 82/100 | 363 | Too concise, missing key elements |
| v7.8.14 | 98/100 | 761 | Restored v7.8.12 quality |
What v7.8.13 Cut (Too Much)
- ❌ Visual architecture diagrams
- ❌ Detailed code examples
- ❌ Non-functional requirements (security/performance)
- ❌ Comprehensive non-goals
What v7.8.14 Restores
- ✅ Full clarification phase (5 questions)
- ✅ Comprehensive PRD structure
- ✅ Detailed personas and functional requirements
- ✅ Architecture considerations
- ✅ Proper 100-point scoring framework
Trade-off Accepted
PRD generation takes ~5-6 minutes but produces 98/100 quality PRDs.
For rapid prototyping, users can ask for a "quick summary" or use natural language like "give me a brief PRD outline".
Upgrade
/octo:update --updateFull changelog: https://github.com/nyldn/claude-octopus/blob/main/CHANGELOG.md